My Open Enrollment Checklist: Why It Took Me 8 Years to Switch to an HDHP

A couple at a kitchen table in the evening reviewing open enrollment health plan options on a laptop, with a notebook of numbers and a calendar with a circled deadline

I paid for a richer health plan for about eight years before my own spending data told me to switch. Here’s the open enrollment checklist I run every year now, and the order I run it in.

Categories:

•

•

6–9 minutes

For most of my career, open enrollment was a box I checked. Pick roughly the same plan as last year, confirm the 401(k) percentage, click submit, get back to work.

The first time I really paid attention was at my first job out of school. That’s where I learned that high-deductible health plans (HDHPs) existed and that only certain plans let you open a health savings account (HSA). As a single guy in my twenties, the decision felt simple. Too simple, it turns out, because I kept defaulting to a plan with higher premiums for years without asking whether I actually used it.

The second time was in 2022, when I got married. Suddenly the questions changed: family coverage instead of self-only, a different set of IRS limits, two people’s health habits instead of one. That was when I started treating open enrollment less like paperwork and more like the design reviews I run at work. Look at the inputs, check the assumptions against real data, make a decision, and write it down.

Many 2027 enrollment windows open in late October and close in November. Here’s the checklist I use now, and the mistake that made me build it.

The mistake: paying for care I didn’t use

I’m in my late thirties, and my wife and I are both relatively healthy. We don’t go to the doctor often. For roughly eight years, I still paid for a plan with higher premiums, as if I expected to.

In retrospect, I didn’t go to the doctor or hospital nearly enough to justify that premium. Switching to an HDHP with an HSA made a big difference in what we pay every year. Looking back, I should have run this comparison years earlier.

I never tracked the exact premium drop, so here’s a reasonable estimate instead. In KFF’s 2025 Employer Health Benefits Survey, the average family premium was $28,272 for a PPO and $25,379 for an HDHP with a savings option, a gap of about $2,900 a year. Workers paid about 26% of family premiums on average, so a typical household might keep roughly $750 of that gap, and some employers pass along more. Most of those eight years I was on single coverage, where the gap is smaller, so call it a few thousand dollars in premiums I didn’t need to pay, before counting the HSA contributions and tax savings I never got to make.

There was a side effect I didn’t expect. The HDHP made us more aware of our health. When every routine visit comes out of your own pocket until you hit the deductible, you start paying attention to the habits that keep you out of the clinic. I wouldn’t pick a plan for that reason, but in the background, it nudged us toward a healthier lifestyle.

The open enrollment checklist I run every year

Five-step house-style diagram of an annual open enrollment review: life changes, last year's real spend, plan math, debt check, fund and automate
The five checks I run, in order, before I submit my elections.

1. What changed in our life? Marriage was my big trigger. A new job, a new house, or a new child changes which coverage tier you need, what limits apply, and how much cash you want on hand. If nothing changed, say so explicitly, and then you can move faster through the rest.

2. What did health care actually cost us last year? This is the step I care about most. Because we’re on an HDHP, our health spending varies from year to year, so I look at the trend, not just one year. For several years I did this the painful way: open the bank account, search keywords for pharmacies and clinics, and type each charge into a spreadsheet. Now I use Monarch to track expenses (I used Mint until it shut down). The tool matters less than having a consistent way to pull the number. If you can’t answer “what did we spend on care last year?” in five minutes, fix that first.

3. Does the plan math still favor the HDHP? I compare total annual cost: premiums plus the out-of-pocket spending we’re likely to have, given the trend from step 2. A plan with higher premiums and no HSA can still be cheaper in a year with a lot of care. I recheck that every year instead of assuming.

4. Is there high-interest debt to clear first? I explain why below. This is where I disagree with the usual “max everything” advice.

5. Fund the accounts, automate them, and stop checking. My employer offers an ESPP, and every year I try to max out both my 401(k) and ESPP contributions. I also review life and disability coverage through work, which I participate in. Once the elections are in, I let payroll do the work.

How I run the plan math

Here’s the shape of the comparison. These are made-up plan numbers for illustration, not mine and not a quote from any employer. Use your own plan documents.

Self-only example (illustrative)Light-care yearModerate-care yearBad year
PPO: $3,000 premiums + out-of-pocket$300 → $3,300$1,000 → $4,000$4,000 max → $7,000
HDHP: $1,200 premiums + out-of-pocket$600 → $1,800$3,000 → $4,200$7,000 max → $8,200
Cheaper plan that yearHDHP by $1,500PPO by $200PPO by $1,200

Two things this table leaves out tip the math further toward the HDHP for people like us. First, HSA contributions are made with pre-tax money, so the HDHP’s real cost is lower than the sticker number. Second, unused HSA money rolls over to the next year, according to IRS Publication 969, so a light-care year builds a balance instead of losing it. If most of your years look like the first column, the premium savings add up fast. If they look like the third, the richer plan may be worth it, and that’s a legitimate choice.

For 2027, the IRS has already set the numbers that define an HSA-eligible plan (Rev. Proc. 2026-24):

2027 IRS limitSelf-onlyFamily
Maximum HSA contribution$4,500$9,000
HDHP minimum deductible$1,750$3,500
HDHP maximum out-of-pocket$8,700$17,400

For comparison, 2026 HSA limits are $4,400 self-only and $8,750 family. The 2026 401(k) employee deferral limit is $24,500; the IRS usually announces the next year’s 401(k) limit in late fall, so check irs.gov before you set your 2027 percentage.

Where I disagree with the usual advice

I agree with most standard open enrollment advice. But “always max the HSA” needs a condition attached. Maxing out the HSA only makes sense to me once higher-interest loans are already paid off. If you’re carrying a really high interest rate, I’d pay that down first and only then focus on the HSA.

So where’s the line for “high interest”? I don’t think there’s one universal number. Everything is relative. I list all of my debts, look at their rates side by side, and draw a line somewhere in the middle. Anything above that line counts as high, and that’s what I pay down first. The line also isn’t fixed: I look at where interest rates are at that point in time, because a loan that looked cheap a few years ago can look different today, and the other way around.

The same goes for the more advanced moves. There are plenty of HSA strategies on YouTube worth learning from, and backdoor-style pathways for people who earn too much for some accounts. I think they’re worth exploring, but only after the basics are covered and the expensive debt is gone. One IRS detail behind a popular HSA strategy: Publication 969 says you can take a tax-free HSA distribution for qualified medical expenses at any time, as long as the expense came after you established the HSA. That’s why some people pay out of pocket now and keep receipts.

What I’d tell a junior engineer at their first open enrollment

Max out the accounts the government set up to help you save, whether that’s a 401(k), a 403(b), or an HSA. They exist for a reason, and the earlier you start, the more time value of money and compound growth can do for you.

Then build the habit and leave it alone. Keep contributing, and don’t check the balance very often. I didn’t appreciate how much these accounts can grow until I looked back a decade into my career. Before you know it, that pot becomes a large number, and it buys you some peace of mind about the future.

And do the plan math with your own numbers, not a coworker’s. A healthy person in their twenties and a family managing a chronic condition should probably pick different plans. Start early, look at your circumstances, and don’t take eight years to ask the question like I did.

If you’re thinking about where these accounts fit in a longer plan, I wrote about why FIRE is a range, not a date on a spreadsheet, and about the Southern California house we bought in 2021. More in Money & FIRE. If you have a question about how you’re approaching your own enrollment this year, send it my way.

This article describes my own experience and a general decision process, not individualized financial, tax, or insurance advice. Plan designs, premiums, employer contributions, and tax situations vary. Check your plan documents and current IRS guidance before you enroll.

About the author

Peter Sun Avatar

Peter Sun, PE, PMP, draws on more than a decade of engineering and medical-device program experience to write about technical work, leadership, AI workflows, career decisions, and financial independence.

More about Engineer & Beyond →

Get the next useful idea in your inbox.

Practical articles on career growth, AI-enabled work, project leadership, and financial independence—without the content-farm noise.

One response to “My Open Enrollment Checklist: Why It Took Me 8 Years to Switch to an HDHP”

  1. […] My Open Enrollment Checklist: Why It Took Me 8 Years to Switch to an HDHP […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *